Mamma Mia!

3
Touring production of the Abba inspired show.
By Becky - 30th Mar 2016

Review of Mamma Mia tourFeaturing the music of Abba, Mamma Mia should be a fun, light-hearted evening of toe-tapping entertainment. Certainly, the storyline lends itself to it; 20-year-old Sophie is about to get married on the small Greek island where her mum runs a tavern. Sophie is desperate to invite her father to the ceremony but not knowing who he is, she invites the three possible candidates hoping that she’ll know him when he arrives. Perhaps, with a different cast, and under different direction, Mamma Mia would have been an altogether more enjoyable evening out, but sadly, last night’s viewing felt like a chore. There were highlights; the group choreography was good, and the enthusiasm from the chorus was admirable. I also enjoyed the staged performances from Donna and the Dynamos; “Super Trooper” and the final performance of “Waterloo,” but overall the show was weak and lacklustre.

Abba songs are notoriously difficult to sing, I realise, but given that this show consists solely of their songs, it baffles me to see actors cast in lead roles who cannot sing well enough in their lower register to be heard. Not only that, but the backing vocals track is turned up so high that also drowns out a lot of the vocals that are in their range, because the main performers are not able to battle against it.

The acting from Lucy May Barker as Sophie was weak; her line delivery exceptionally poor. Because of this, it is hard for an audience to feel any emotion for her at all. I was so unconcerned by Phillip Ryan’s presence, as Sky, that I couldn’t pick him out at the end. As Sophie’s potential fathers, Richard Standing, Tim Walton and Christopher Hollis were okay at best, but clearly nowhere within the right age range, Richard Standing looked as though he was the same age as the daughter he could have possibly fathered.

As Donna Sheridan, Sara Poyzer turned in a decent performance, and Jacqueline Braun and Emma Clifford as her two best friends were certainly the strongest cast members, but this show seems to be waiting to get from one musical number to another, with little to no thought to the dialogue in between. To me, that doesn’t constitute a good piece of theatre.

I was certainly far from the only one who felt it; after the interval we counted no less than fourteen empty seats around us, which to me seems unnecessarily harsh but is certainly a sign that the show is not up to standard. There were not many laughs forthcoming from the audience, but it seemed as though the entire place was waiting for the inevitable medley at the end, because at that point everyone got to their feet and started to dance and cheer.

One woman in the bar likened it to being stuck on a raucous hen night and I guess that’s the crux of it; if you’re looking for an evening out with a group of friends where you’re guaranteed plenty of sexual innuendo jokes and a sing along at the end, you could do worse than this. If you enjoy immersing yourself in a compelling and enjoyable piece of theatre, you’d be better to avoid it.

Becky Fuller


Latest News & Reviews

14th Aug 22 :: Review: Myra Dubois' A Problem Shared
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
14th Aug 22 :: Review: The Thinking Drinkers
Pup Quiz - seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
14th Aug 22 :: Review: The Greatest Hits of Lily and John
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
14th Aug 22 :: Review: Eh Up, Me Old Flowers!
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
14th Aug 22 :: Review: 9 Circles
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
14th Aug 22 :: Review: Helter Skelter
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
2
12th Aug 22 :: Review: The Giant KIllers
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
12th Aug 22 :: Review: Candy
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
12th Aug 22 :: Review: Fabulett 1933
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
12th Aug 22 :: Review: Godspell
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
11th Aug 22 :: Review: The Beast Will Rise
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
2
11th Aug 22 :: Review: Lizard Boy
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
11th Aug 22 :: Review: I Just Like You
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
11th Aug 22 :: Review: Twinkle
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
3
11th Aug 22 :: Review: Porno
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
5
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Cafe van Der Brocke
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
10th Aug 22 :: Review: You're Dead, Mate
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Dedication
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
4
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Bare
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
2
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Bat Out of Hell
Touring production seen at the Bristol Hippodrome.
5

Most Popular Stories

8th Aug 22 :: Review: Sugar?
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Cirque Alfonse
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
9th Aug 22 :: Review: Wreckage
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
8th Aug 22 :: Review: Briefs: Sweatshop
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Bat Out of Hell
Touring production seen at the Bristol Hippodrome.
10th Aug 22 :: Review: You're Dead, Mate
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Cafe van Der Brocke
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
8th Aug 22 :: Review: Let's Try Gay
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
8th Aug 22 :: Review: Soho Boy
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe
10th Aug 22 :: Review: Spank!
Seen at the Edinburgh Fringe

SeatChoice Blog

Society for Theatre Research Theatre Book Prize – Winner

The winner of the Society for Theatre Research Theatre Book Prize 2022 has been announced


Theatre Research Theatre Book Prize 2022

The Society for Theatre Research reveals the shortlist for the Theatre Book Prize 2022.


Originals Playwriting Award 2022

New playwriting award from Original Theatre.


New on-demand platform from Sadler’s Wells

Sadler’s Wells Digital Stage launches its Video on Demand platform with Birmingham Royal Ballet’s Curated by Carlos


An online resource for young children in Welsh

To coincide with World Storytelling Day, Theatre Company launches online resource for young children to access original Welsh language stories.



© Dynamic Listing Ltd, UK
1995-2022
PRIVACY and GDPR
Listings powered by Dynamic Listing Ltd
Multidomain certificate installed