Mary Poppins. Practically Perfect?

5
I have a bit of a soft spot for the Disney film of Mary Poppins, so I have been looking forward with mixed anticipation and dread to the stage adaptation. When I saw it, it was only their fifth performance (still in preview) and I was sat on a bench seat
By Robert Iles - 19th Sep 2004
The new adaptation of Mary Poppins for the stage has taken Cameron Mackintosh some 25 to bring to the stage, longer even than the 20 years it took Disney to get the film going! What is it that has made these stories so seemingly hard to take on and yet has made these teams so persistent in their pursuit? The reason is partly that PL Travers was very protective of her stories and wanted to make sure they were handled sympathetically. Having been disappointed by the film she was reluctant to let the stage rights go but was eventually persuaded by Cameron Mackintosh that he could do the job. But even then, Cameron had to both assemble a team capable of undertaking the project and also wait until the time was right for the show to appear.

Cameron had managed to persuade Mrs Travers (as she liked to be known despite being unmarried) that there were many aspects of the original film that should be carried over, so he entered into a collaboration with Disney, personified in this case by Thomas Schumacher of their Theatrical Division.

But this is most assuredly not the film. Whilst a number of the Sherman brothers’ songs, often in new adaptations, appear in this show, and it has many visual echoes of the film, the storyline and feel owe much more to the original books. This is still a family show but there is more humour, more depth and a lot more story than the film ever attempted.

As an adult in the audience, you will be happy to see some old favourites but even happier that there is now a real story, some very funny lines and some wonderful theatrical moments. If you take young kids, they’ll love the spectacle, songs and magic but do expect them to climb on your knee for a cuddle once or twice as the blacker aspects of the original stories come through. The sugary niceness of the film is no longer there; the kids are unpleasant, and the wicked get their come-uppance.

Cameron has pulled together a family to produce this show, there is a real ensemble feel to the piece, it is not a showcase for a star or two just an honest to goodness good musical. The designs (Bob Crowley) are superb, both technically and visually, with enormous attention to detail that will mean I’ll be able to watch the show several times and still find new bits. Matthew Bourne’s choreography, aided by Stephen Mear, fills the stage in the big numbers (I think you might miss some of the great set pieces from the stalls, try to get a higher seat!) and there are some wonderful set pieces, in particular Supercalifrag .. well, you know what I mean.

George Stiles and Anthony Drewe have produced some absolutely enchanting new songs and adaptations of the old favourites. I hear from that at least one cast member was convinced until recently that “Anything can happen” actually was in the movie. It is an enormous tribute to them that I’m already humming their tunes along with the originals and, in a year or two I may also forget which are which.

The children were fantastic, we saw Harry Stott and Charlotte Spencer in the roles of Michael and Jane. These are pivotal roles in the show, an enormous amount of the action, pace and story is entrusted to them and yet

Laura Michelle Kelly’s performance as Mary Poppins, from first appearance to final, magical, departure, is a true delight. On reflection, Mary Poppins actually doesn’t have a huge role (in the stage sense) in this musical; she is the catalyst and the force, often an observer on stage rather than a ‘star’.

David Haig’s Mr Banks worked perfectly for me with just the right mix of vulnerability, angst and delight. Winifred Bansk, struggling to meet his expectations and seemingly failing at every attempt was given real depth in a charming performance by Linzi Hateley.

But for me, the real revelation was the character of Bert, I finally see the crucial role this character plays in the stories. Played superbly by Gavin Lee with an energy and commitment that made this exhausting role look easy.

The cast as a whole were wonderful. There are actually too many really good moments in the show to individually name; the bank, the revenge of the toys (Valentine was excellent), Miss Andrew gets her come-uppance. I’d say that “A spoonful of Sugar” still looks a little pantomime slapstick rather than magic and some lessons in kite flying might not go amiss but other than that, no gripes, no shadows on a glorious evening.

Did I miss the Disney animation sequences, penguins, cod accents, film and cartoon effects of the movie? No, frankly I didn’t. The settings and dancing are more than a match for the film and when you see the magic on stage it is just so much more, well, magical! The film never made me want to read the books, this stage play has. PL Travers would be delighted. Thank you Cameron, and your team, for getting it spit-spot-on!

You may get the impression from this review that I was somewhat taken with this new show. You’re right! On just about every level from family show to a good night of theatre to a technical When it settles into its stride I will happily see it again, I reckon London is about to see a new long-term resident; practically perfect in every way.

Robert Iles


Latest News & Reviews

25th Apr 24 :: Review: Nye
NT Live broadcast seen at The Regal in Wadebridge
4
21st Apr 24 :: Review: Calendar Girls
Seen at the Mill at Sonning.
4
16th Apr 24 :: Review: Pretty Woman
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
3
15th Apr 24 :: Olivier Awards 2024
The winners of this year's Olivier Awards
10th Apr 24 :: Review: Come From Away
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
5
5th Apr 24 :: Review: Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Seen at The Phoenix Theatre, London
5
2nd Apr 24 :: Review: Everybody's Talkling About Jamie
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
5
28th Mar 24 :: Review: The Wizard of Oz
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
4
27th Mar 24 :: Critics Circle Awards
The winners of this year's Critics' Circle Theatre Awards have been announced.
22nd Mar 24 :: Review: The Motive and the Cue
Live broadcast seen at the Regal Cinema, Wadebridge.
5
12th Mar 24 :: Review: Macbeth
English Touring Theatre (ETT) production seen in Worthing,
3
7th Mar 24 :: Review: The Life of Pi
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
5
6th Mar 24 :: Review: And Then There Were None
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
2
5th Mar 24 :: Review: Musclebound
Seen at The Front Room, Weston-super-Mare
3
2nd Mar 24 :: Review: Marry Me A Little
Seen at The Stage Door Theatre, Drury Lane
2
28th Feb 24 :: Review: Cable Street
Seen at the Southwark Playhouse, Borough.
3
28th Feb 24 :: Review: Carlos Acosta - On Before
Seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
4
26th Feb 24 :: Offies Winners 2024
WInners of the Offies 2024 awards have been announced.
15th Feb 24 :: Review: The Drifters Girl
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
4
12th Feb 24 :: Review: Whatsonstage Awards Winners
The winners of the Whatsonstage Awards announced.
0

Most Popular Stories

Viewings over the last 14 days
 
Calendar Girls
Seen at the Mill at Sonning.
Posted 21st Apr 24 :: 280 views
Birmingham Royal Ballet - Black Sabbath
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
Posted 13th Oct 23 :: 203 views
Pretty Woman
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
Posted 16th Apr 24 :: 197 views
Everybody's Talkling About Jamie
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
Posted 2nd Apr 24 :: 168 views
Come From Away
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
Posted 10th Apr 24 :: 161 views
Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Seen at The Phoenix Theatre, London
Posted 5th Apr 24 :: 125 views
Macbeth
English Touring Theatre (ETT) production seen in Worthing,
Posted 12th Mar 24 :: 115 views
The Wizard of Oz
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
Posted 28th Mar 24 :: 115 views
Olivier Awards 2024
The winners of this year's Olivier Awards
Posted 15th Apr 24 :: 115 views
Critics Circle Awards
The winners of this year's Critics' Circle Theatre Awards have been announced.
Posted 27th Mar 24 :: 112 views
The Motive and the Cue
Live broadcast seen at the Regal Cinema, Wadebridge.
Posted 22nd Mar 24 :: 108 views
And Then There Were None
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
Posted 6th Mar 24 :: 75 views
The Life of Pi
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
Posted 7th Mar 24 :: 65 views
The Drifters Girl
Touring production seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth.
Posted 15th Feb 24 :: 48 views
Carlos Acosta - On Before
Seen at the Theatre Royal Plymouth
Posted 28th Feb 24 :: 48 views
Musclebound
Seen at The Front Room, Weston-super-Mare
Posted 5th Mar 24 :: 45 views
Nye
NT Live broadcast seen at The Regal in Wadebridge
Posted 25th Apr 24 :: 45 views
Dangerous Giant Animals - Underbelly
Christina Murdock
Posted 24th Aug 18 :: 40 views
Cable Street
Seen at the Southwark Playhouse, Borough.
Posted 28th Feb 24 :: 39 views
Alegria - Cirque du Soleil
The latest production seen at the Royal Albert Hall
Posted 19th Jan 24 :: 39 views

Listings powered by Dynamic Listing Ltd
Mastodon X - Twitter Multidomain certificate installed
© Dynamic Listing Ltd, UK. 1995-2024